Nikki Angioli (Emma Roberts) works overseas in a big city, but has to return home to Little Italy, where her family owns a pizza restaurant, to renew her visa.

While there, she falls for Leo (Hayden Christensen), who belongs to the Campo family. The Campos own a competing Italian restaurant and Nikki realizes that a romance with Leo would not be welcomed by her father. She has to figure out how to proceed in order not to escalate the feud between their families.